PAA: Sell vs Hold vs Inherit

500 units of Plains All American Pipeline — breakeven price, tax comparison, §1014 step-up analysis.

This tool provides projections based on assumptions. It does not constitute tax, legal, or investment advice. Consult a qualified CPA or financial advisor before making decisions based on this output.

Position: 500 units of Plains All American Pipeline at $20/unit

Tax assumptions: 32% bracket, MFJ, NIIT, §199A QBI deduction. Unit appreciation: 3.5%/year.

Should You Sell PAA or Hold?

We computed three exit strategies for each holding period: sell now, hold and collect distributions, and hold with no sale by you. Every number comes from the IRS Partner's Basis Worksheet.

5-Year Horizon

Sell Now

Proceeds: $10,350

Tax: -$297

Net: $10,053

Hold 5 Years, Then Sell

Distributions: $4,064

Dist. tax: -$239

Terminal FMV: $11,877

Exit tax: -$1,619

Net: $14,083

Hold to Year 20, No Sale by You

Value at year 20: $11,877

Sale tax: none (no sale by you in this column); a sale in year 20 would carry $1,619

Total: $15,702

Separately, if the units pass at death: Successor’s basis if the units pass at death: generally the fair market value at that date (or at the alternate valuation date where the executor elects under §2032), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent; this is the outside basis only, and the partnership’s basis in its property, from which a §751 amount on a later sale is figured, is adjusted only with a §754 election or a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer (R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). The successor’s tax on a later sale is not computed.

Breakeven Price

$35/unit

Selling only makes sense above this price over a 5-year horizon.

10-Year Horizon

Sell Now

Proceeds: $10,350

Tax: -$297

Net: $10,053

Hold 10 Years, Then Sell

Distributions: $11,262

Dist. tax: -$662

Terminal FMV: $14,106

Exit tax: -$3,651

Net: $21,055

Hold to Year 20, No Sale by You

Value at year 20: $14,106

Sale tax: none (no sale by you in this column); a sale in year 20 would carry $3,651

Total: $24,706

Separately, if the units pass at death: Successor’s basis if the units pass at death: generally the fair market value at that date (or at the alternate valuation date where the executor elects under §2032), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent; this is the outside basis only, and the partnership’s basis in its property, from which a §751 amount on a later sale is figured, is adjusted only with a §754 election or a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer (R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). The successor’s tax on a later sale is not computed.

Breakeven Price

$57/unit

Selling only makes sense above this price over a 10-year horizon.

15-Year Horizon

Sell Now

Proceeds: $10,350

Tax: -$297

Net: $10,053

Hold 15 Years, Then Sell

Distributions: $21,839

Dist. tax: -$2,813

Terminal FMV: $16,753

Exit tax: -$4,740

Net: $31,039

Hold to Year 20, No Sale by You

Value at year 20: $16,753

Sale tax: none (no sale by you in this column); a sale in year 20 would carry $4,740

Total: $35,779

Separately, if the units pass at death: Successor’s basis if the units pass at death: generally the fair market value at that date (or at the alternate valuation date where the executor elects under §2032), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent; this is the outside basis only, and the partnership’s basis in its property, from which a §751 amount on a later sale is figured, is adjusted only with a §754 election or a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer (R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). The successor’s tax on a later sale is not computed.

Breakeven Price

$84/unit

Selling only makes sense above this price over a 15-year horizon.

20-Year Horizon

Sell Now

Proceeds: $10,350

Tax: -$297

Net: $10,053

Hold 20 Years, Then Sell

Distributions: $37,380

Dist. tax: -$6,064

Terminal FMV: $19,898

Exit tax: -$5,876

Net: $45,338

Hold to Year 20, No Sale by You

Value at year 20: $19,898

Sale tax: none (no sale by you in this column); a sale in year 20 would carry $5,876

Total: $51,214

Separately, if the units pass at death: Successor’s basis if the units pass at death: generally the fair market value at that date (or at the alternate valuation date where the executor elects under §2032), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent; this is the outside basis only, and the partnership’s basis in its property, from which a §751 amount on a later sale is figured, is adjusted only with a §754 election or a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer (R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). The successor’s tax on a later sale is not computed.

Breakeven Price

$122/unit

Selling only makes sense above this price over a 20-year horizon.

Bottom Line

Holding 19 more years with no sale by you produces $41,161 more in this projection than selling today: the units' projected value of $19,898 (no tax deducted) plus net distributions, against the after-tax proceeds of a sale today. A sale by you at that projected value would carry $5,876 in tax, of which ~$20,000 is the §751 amount; neither figure is a measure of tax saved or avoided at death. Selling now produces more than holding in this projection only above $122.08/unit.

Run your own numbers in the Portfolio Simulator →

PAA’s non-linear, COVID-era basis path makes its math distinct from steady eroders — compare PAA across MLP archetypes.

← Compare sell-vs-hold across all MLPs

MLP Estate Planning — Full Series

Computed by lucasandersen.ai MLP Tax Simulator v0.1.0. 2026-11-05. Not tax advice.